Meadville Tribune

Breaking News

Local News

September 15, 2012

SUNDAY ISSUE: Cost of Sept. 11 memorial

NEW YORK — A debate over balancing the need to honor the memory of Sept. 11 with the enormous costs of running a memorial and museum at ground zero was reawakened last week on the eve of the attacks’ 11th anniversary, as officials faced questions Monday over the project’s expected $60 million-a-year operating budget and an agreement paving the way for the museum’s completion was reached.

The number comes on top of the $700 million construction cost of the National September 11 Memorial & Museum. A report last Sunday by The Associated Press noted that $12 million a year would be spent on security, more than the entire operating budgets of Gettysburg National Military Park and the monument that includes the USS Arizona Memorial at Pearl Harbor.

Mayor Michael Bloomberg, who leads the board of the nonprofit foundation that controls the museum and memorial, on Monday called the memorial’s operating cost a necessity for security and other costs unique to hosting millions of visitors a year on the reborn site of two terror attacks, in 1993 and 2001.

Some congressional Democrats underscored their efforts to help get federal money to cover some of the operating cost, while a Republican senator reiterated his opposition. Even some victims’ family members are divided over whether the annual price tag represents the price of paying tribute to the nearly 3,000 lives lost or the cost of unnecessary grandeur.

At ground zero, several visitors to the memorial plaza last week were surprised but not put off by the $60 million-a-year figure.

“Really?” said Pat Lee, a Wal-Mart manager from Atlanta. But, she said, “I don’t think the money is too much. Because it’s important to keep alive the memory of what happened.”

The memorial, the centerpiece of the rebuilt World Trade Center site, includes a serene, solemn memorial plaza, where waterfalls fill the fallen towers’ footprints, and a mostly underground museum that is to house such artifacts as the staircase workers used to escape the attacks.

The plaza opened last year and has drawn 4.5 million visitors. The museum was to have been finished by Tuesday, but progress stopped amid a construction costs fight between the memorial foundation and the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, the agency that owns the trade center site. The Port Authority claimed the memorial foundation owed it $300 million for infrastructure and revised project costs; the foundation argued it was owed money because of project delays.

The parties involved in the dispute said they had reached an agreement. Their memorandum of understanding addresses issues including coordination of the site and general financial terms but doesn’t go into detail on specific levels of financing. The agreement outlines that the memorial will have six months’ operating expenses on hand as net working capital and that it will give the Port Authority a security deposit equal to six months’ utility expenses, but it doesn’t say what those figures are.

Even so, it remains unclear how the foundation will cover the costs of running the museum, once it does open.

So far, the foundation has been able to rely on corporate and individual donations and selling memorabilia. The annual expense was about $27.8 million last year, including four months of operating the memorial plaza, according to recently audited financial statements.

But the expense is projected to jump to $60 million after the museum opens. The foundation plans to spend around $12 million a year on private security; operating the waterfalls costs another $4.5 million to $5 million annually, the foundation says.

Foundation officials haven’t responded to requests for information about other costs at the site.

“Nobody is taking the money and building a hunting lodge for the trustees or having caviar and Champagne every night,” Bloomberg said when asked about the operating expenses after an unrelated news conference. “It’s a lot of money, but it costs that. Do you want a real budget, or do you want us to lie?”

He said the costs could be covered by donations, by admission tickets to the museum — the price has not been set, but the memorial president has suggested it could be up to $20 — and from federal aid. A proposal for up to $20 million a year in federal money has hit roadblocks.

Senate sponsors Daniel Inouye, D-Hawaii, and New York Democrats Kirsten Gillibrand and Charles Schumer said through their offices Monday that they continued to press for the money.

“This is hallowed ground, and it deserves to be treated like other national monuments,” Schumer said in an emailed statement.

Sen. Tom Coburn, R-Okla., has been blocking the measure. And he’s not relenting, spokesman John Hart said Monday.

“He believes it is wrong to pay for this by borrowing $200 million from future generations and foreign governments when the federal government is rife with waste and duplication,” Hart said.

The Sept. 11 memorial would be more costly to run than some of the other places where the nation remembers its dead — Arlington National Cemetery, which receives 4 million visitors a year, costs $45 million annually, and Gettysburg National Military Park $8.4 million.

Text Only
Local News
  • Deadline approaches for local scholarship application

    Crawford County residents seeking or continuing a career in engineering, manufacturing, tool and die or plastic molding have until June 3 to apply for up to $4,000 in scholarships.

    May 20, 2013

  • Scam falsely using name of local hospital

    A phone scam is falsely using the name of a local hospital.
     

    May 20, 2013

  • Interstate 79 northbound down one lane until tonight

    Interstate 79 northbound is restricted to one-lane traffic in Crawford County from Exit 141 (Geneva/Cochranton, Route 285) to Exit 147A (Meadville, Route 6 east, Route 322 east) due to roadwork.

    May 20, 2013

  • Fighting multiple sclerosis one step at a time

    The Western Pennsylvania Chapter of the National Multiple Sclerosis Society crossed the finish line of a successful 2013 event season with its Meadville MS Walk in Roche Park on Sunday afternoon, according to organizers and participants.

    May 20, 2013

  • MON maplewood.jpg Maplewood 'scores' funds toward new scoreboard

    On June 7, Ethan Moody will make the ceremonial journey across the stage to receive his high school diploma. Soon thereafter, he will bid farewell to Maplewood Junior-Senior High School before advancing onto the next stage in his life.

    May 20, 2013 1 Photo

  • SUN gardens.jpg Master Gardeners lead charge to get park planted

    The flowers at Mary B. DeArment Memorial Park don’t just spring up out of the ground.
    The year-round maintenance of Penn State Master Gardeners of Crawford County and additional volunteers ensures a colorful welcome to Meadville, according to members who spent their Saturday morning in the group’s culminating effort, its annual DeArment Park Planting.

    May 19, 2013 1 Photo

  • 5/18/13 SLIDESHOW: DeArment Park Planting

    Click photo for slideshow

    May 18, 2013

  • Technology speeds disaster alerts, response

    Caitria O’Neill remembers her reaction to hearing tornado warnings on June 1, 2011. She went to the grocery store and said, “because I live in Massachusetts, and we don’t get tornadoes.”

    May 18, 2013

  • Primary could decide Vernon supervisors spot

    With three Republican candidates running for nomination and no opposing Democrats, the race for a spot on the Vernon Township Board of Supervisors could be decided this spring.

    May 18, 2013

  • Communication key in keeping public safe during disaster

    When bad weather is closing in on Crawford County, communication is key in keeping the public safe, according to Allen Clark, director of Emergency Management for the Crawford County Office of Emergency Services.

    May 18, 2013 1 Story

Business Marquee
AP Video
Company Promises to Make All Snail Mail Digital Analyst: Tumblr Fills Void in Yahoo's Offerings Commuters Face Delays After Conn. Train Accident Raw: Swarm of Tornadoes Slams Plains Raw: Fierce Bombing in Qusair, Syria RAW: TV Staff Take Cover From Tornado Raw: Accused US Spy Reportedly Leaves Russia AP CEO: Records Seizure 'Unconstitutional' Fatal Hot Air Balloon Accident in Turkey Tornadoes, Storms Strike Midwest 'Babyland': Camp Lejeune's Toxic Legacy? Raw: Heavy Tornado Damage in Shawnee, Okla NTSB Begins Investigation Into Conn. Train Crash Could Tobacco Be the Next Biofuel?
Hyperlocal Search
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide
Stocks