12/30/08 — ERIE — Erie County Court of Common Pleas has thrown out a defamation lawsuit filed against outgoing Republican Congressman Phil English, whose district included most of Crawford County.
Erie County Judge John Garhart has dismissed the defamation lawsuit Steven Porter and Rita Porter had filed October 2006 against English and English’s campaign committee, People for English.
Steven Porter and his wife, Rita, alleged was Porter was defamed by English in the 2004 and 2006 Congressional campaigns.
The suit had claimed English has “maliciously misrepresented” Porter’s views in print and TV advertisements during the 2004 campaign and the 2006 Congressional campaign by taking quotes from a 1991 textbook written by Steven Porter, “The Ethics of a Democracy,” out of context. Porter was a registered Democrat at the time and English’s opponent in the 2004 and 2006 campaigns, losing both times to English.
The suit was filed in Erie County Court of Common Pleas because English lives in Erie County and People for English Committee is located there, too. A lawsuit must be filed in the district where the alleged wrongdoing happened.
English’s campaign ads said Porter favored state-backed sterilization of mental patients and others, legalized prostitution, and stripping vote rights from those judged to be insufficiently intelligent.
Porter responded the book was designed to spark class discussion and didn’t represent his personal views. He claimed the book clearly indicated the scenarios weren’t meant to represent his personal views.
English, who is leaving office in the next few days, hailed the dismissal of what he calls a “frivolous lawsuit from the start.” English was defeated by Democrat Kathy Dahlkemper in November’s general election.
“This decision is a complete vindication of our campaign and our message,” said English. “This clearly clears the air.”
“The local courts are choked with real business,” he said. “This crass abuse of the legal process cost the taxpayers, as well as my family, thousands of dollars. Fortunately, this decision restores my reputation and clears the record.”
Walter Cohen, English’s attorney, said the lawsuit was abusive from the start.
“It’s strange to suggest that by quoting directly from Mr. Porter’s book and public statements in legitimate political discourse, my client defamed him,” Cohen said in a statement.
Contacted by the Tribune at his home Monday, Porter declined to comment on the lawsuit’s dismissal.
However, Porter was willing to comment on English’s referring a related matter concerning Porter to the U.S. Attorney for the Western District of Pennsylvania.
English said there is information that suggests Porter used campaign funds to finance his lawsuit against English in violation of federal campaign law. At English’s request, Cohen has referred the matter to the U.S. Attorney’s Office.
Porter said he asked the Federal Elections Commission officials about using the campaign funds for the lawsuit and had received permission since he had loaned his campaign the money.
“Mr. English just continues to be as vicious as he can be,” Porter said. “I’m at a loss to describe my feelings.”
Local News
Porter suit against English thrown out
- Local News
-
-
City leaders not concerned after financial downgrade
During the past five years, Moody’s Investors Service has assigned three different ratings — all within the range of “upper medium grade” to the City of Meadville’s bonds. In 2007, the city was given a rating of A3, the lowest of the trio. In 2010, the city’s bond rating was raised to A1, the highest ranking in the “upper medium” category. Monday, Moody’s gave the city’s $10,000,000 General Obligation Bonds, Series of 2012, which went on the market Monday, the middle rating of A2.
-
Elderly, disabled and their caregivers have tremendous new local resource
The new Crawford County Link isn’t a place, but an information network to help people age 60 and older or those between 18 and 59 with disabilities stay living independently.
-
County's median age rising as population still stable
Crawford Countians are growing older and aging in place.
-
Crawford Central yearlong pay freeze plan fails
Differences over details have derailed a contract featuring a one-year pay freeze for Crawford Central School district teachers, leaving district administrators looking for ways to close an unexpectedly large 2012-13 budget gap.
-
Saegertown singer has date with CMT
A Saegertown man will appear on the Country Music Television (CMT) show “Singing Bee” on June 1 at 8 and 11 p.m.
-
Court ruling means county politicking can continue
A proposed resolution to limit Crawford County employees from serving as a chair or vice chair of a political party can’t be enacted because of a Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruling in a Montgomery County case.
-
Officials: Rape suspect kills himself before trial
A Crawford County jail inmate died at an Erie hospital early Saturday morning in the wake of an apparent suicide attempt, according to county officials.
-
Cambridge radio station offers soundtrack of local music scene
Lately, “I’ve been having a heavy-duty highlight on local artists every other hour,” Sam Reese said as he sat at the controls of WXCS 92.9 recently, queuing up the current block of tunes lined up for play.
- NEW LOCAL: Crawford County jail inmate dies at Erie hospital
- NEW LOCAL: Fire destroys Cambridge Springs area barn and dairy herd
- More Local News Headlines
-
City leaders not concerned after financial downgrade
FAMU Bandmates: Victim Volunteered to Be Hazed
Raw Video: Bride Who Faked Cancer Released
Raw Video: Tornado Appears During Wedding
HP to Cut 27,000 Jobs, Save Up to $3.5B
Inquiry Hears Wider Secret Service Misbehavior
Md. 911 Dispatcher Caught Sleeping on Job
Raw Video: Toddler Trapped in Washing Machine
Iowa Man With Zebra, Parrot in Truck Gets DUI
Egyptians Pick New President in Free Election
Giant Bull Head Draws Drivers to South Dakota
Astrodome Fades As Houston Decides Fate
Franciscan Files Tell Stories of Priest Abuse
Wildfire Destroys 2 Homes
Flight Diverted After Suspicious Note
Joplin Remembers Deadly Tornado, 1 Year Later
Panel Recommends Against Routine Prostate Test
Fired Lingerie Employee Claims Discrimination
Facebook Shares Continue Negative Slide
Cuba Waiting for Cyber Age to Come
8 Hurt in Oklahoma Shooting After NBA Playoff
