Meadville Tribune

Local News

December 29, 2008

Porter suit against English thrown out

12/30/08 — ERIE — Erie County Court of Common Pleas has thrown out a defamation lawsuit filed against outgoing Republican Congressman Phil English, whose district included most of Crawford County.

Erie County Judge John Garhart has dismissed the defamation lawsuit Steven Porter and Rita Porter had filed October 2006 against English and English’s campaign committee, People for English.

Steven Porter and his wife, Rita, alleged was Porter was defamed by English in the 2004 and 2006 Congressional campaigns.

The suit had claimed English has “maliciously misrepresented” Porter’s views in print and TV advertisements during the 2004 campaign and the 2006 Congressional campaign by taking quotes from a 1991 textbook written by Steven Porter, “The Ethics of a Democracy,” out of context. Porter was a registered Democrat at the time and English’s opponent in the 2004 and 2006 campaigns, losing both times to English.

The suit was filed in Erie County Court of Common Pleas because English lives in Erie County and People for English Committee is located there, too. A lawsuit must be filed in the district where the alleged wrongdoing happened.

English’s campaign ads said Porter favored state-backed sterilization of mental patients and others, legalized prostitution, and stripping vote rights from those judged to be insufficiently intelligent.

Porter responded the book was designed to spark class discussion and didn’t represent his personal views. He claimed the book clearly indicated the scenarios weren’t meant to represent his personal views.

English, who is leaving office in the next few days, hailed the dismissal of what he calls a “frivolous lawsuit from the start.” English was defeated by Democrat Kathy Dahlkemper in November’s general election.

“This decision is a complete vindication of our campaign and our message,” said English. “This clearly clears the air.”

“The local courts are choked with real business,” he said. “This crass abuse of the legal process cost the taxpayers, as well as my family, thousands of dollars. Fortunately, this decision restores my reputation and clears the record.”

Walter Cohen, English’s attorney, said the lawsuit was abusive from the start.

“It’s strange to suggest that by quoting directly from Mr. Porter’s book and public statements in legitimate political discourse, my client defamed him,” Cohen said in a statement.

Contacted by the Tribune at his home Monday, Porter declined to comment on the lawsuit’s dismissal.

However, Porter was willing to comment on English’s referring a related matter concerning Porter to the U.S. Attorney for the Western District of Pennsylvania.

English said there is information that suggests Porter used campaign funds to finance his lawsuit against English in violation of federal campaign law. At English’s request, Cohen has referred the matter to the U.S. Attorney’s Office.

Porter said he asked the Federal Elections Commission officials about using the campaign funds for the lawsuit and had received permission since he had loaned his campaign the money.

“Mr. English just continues to be as vicious as he can be,” Porter said. “I’m at a loss to describe my feelings.”

Text Only
Local News
Business Marquee
AP Video
Man Killed in Courthouse Shootout Video of Ga. Man Who Killed Girl Released Air Force Airlines: Leaders Get Polished Service Ga Girl Fights Off Kidnapper at Walmart Nevada Highway Patrol, City Settle Beating Case White House Attacks Romney on Birth Control Homs Bombardment Continues, Global Outcry Grows Mo. Teen Gets Life Sentence for Killing Girl, 9 Lower-hassle Screening to Be Tested at Airports Raw Video: Dog Rescued From Icy Colo. Water Helmet Camera Captures Calif. Fire Rescue Worker Tells 911: Powell 'exploded the House' Triple Win: Santorum Takes Minn., Mo., Colo. Injured Marine Inspired by Homecoming No Rape Charges Against Son of NYPD Commissioner Egypt's Ruling Generals Play Risky Game With US Former Komen Exec Defends Funding Cut Skip the Coffee Cup and Inhale Your Caffeine Fix Calif. Gay Marriage Ban Ruled Unconstitutional Jury Selection for Ex-UVa Athlete Enters 2nd Day
Poll

Mitt Romney has surged to major campaign wins in recent weeks. If he is the GOP candidate for president:

The Democrats are in trouble; he’s overcoming tough challenges now and learning from them
He will have no chance against incumbent Barack Obama
It’s too early to tell, but Romney would probably be in trouble
It’s too early to tell, but Romney should have a good chance against Obama
     View Results
Hyperlocal Search
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide
Popular Searches
Powered by Local.com
Stocks